- Top
- A - Z
?
This menu's updates are based on your activity. The data is only saved locally (on your computer) and never transferred to us. You can click these links to clear your history or disable it.
More... (full list)

Results for : straight gay first time

×
Mode
Default
Period
Ever
Length
All
Video quality
1080P+
Viewed videos
Show all
- Show all
- Hide

Guys In Sweat Pants

Straight guys have their first gay experience

408.7k 99% 6min - 1080p

seducing straight guy

10k 86% 2min - 1080p

BAIT BUS - Trust Us, It’s Not Gay The First Time You Fuck A Dude

207.8k 100% 12min - 1080p

straight boy takes dick

237k 44% 10min - 1080p

FTM Jock Rubs Pussy And Uses Vibrator

344.4k 97% 8min - 1080p

Latin Leche - Sexy Latino Guy Rams A Boy’s Asshole

587.7k 98% 13min - 1080p

Straight guys enjoying themselves

29.8k 90% 18sec - 1080p

Straight Felon's First Time Gay Experience

38.9k 100% 8min - 1080p

ActiveDuty Official

Muscular Str8 Military Guy Fucks his Friend Bareback

120.4k 100% 10min - 1080p

Hot Latino Twink Fucks StepBro's Straight Young Buddy For Money

3.4M 100% 8min - 1080p

NextDoorStudios Official

Sexy Country Guy Has Gay Sex For The First Time Ever!!

1.9M 100% 10min - 1080p

Skinny Young Twink Agrees To Have Sex With Gay Mall Cop After Learning He Used To Fuck His Sister

1.4M 100% 8min - 1080p

BAITBUS - It’s Not Gay The First Time, That's What We Tell Him LOL

167.7k 100% 12min - 1080p

NextDoorStudios Official

1st time raw sex practice for str8 roomie before his party

611.8k 100% 10min - 1080p

ActiveDuty Official

Best Of First Timers

542.9k 100% 43min - 1080p

Young Curious Amateur Straight Latino Studs Fuck For Cash For Filmmaker

548.6k 98% 8min - 1080p

ActiveDuty Official

Logan Lane Blows Dick For The First Time

213k 100% 13min - 1080p

NextDoorStudios Official

NextDoorStudios - Guy Initiates Straight Guy Into Fraternity

164.1k 100% 10min - 1080p

DisruptiveFilms

First Time With Mindful Escort

970.1k 100% 25min - 1080p

Red Head Pounded out by boyfriend and bi guy creating amazing sex.

3.9M 97% 15min - 1080p

DisruptiveFilms

Inexperienced Twink Has First Anal Sex

317.3k 100% 18min - 1080p

BAITBUS - Str8 Guy Gets His Dick Sucked By A Gay Guy And He's Not Too Happy About It

800.5k 100% 10min - 1080p

First Threeway For Hot Amateur Jocks

214.7k 100% 14min - 1080p

Gay Athletic boy lets Straight Dude FUCK HIM

2.3M 100% 11min - 1080p

Young Latino Teen Boy Brings Straight Buddy Sex For Money While Being Recorded

1.7M 100% 8min - 1080p

ActiveDuty Official

Shy Str8 Army Guy Does Bareback Gay Sex

68.6k 100% 10min - 1080p

ActiveDuty Official

Straight Soldier Bareback Fucked by Big Dick Hunk

299k 99% 10min - 1080p

Masculine Jason - Jason Collins

Jason Collins Fucks a Straight Guy!

136.7k 100% 38min - 1080p

NextDoorStudios Official

Straight Guy Opens Up For Improv Session

78.4k 100% 10min - 1080p

DisruptiveFilms

Married Guy Has Romantic First Gay Fuck

1.7M 100% 22min - 1080p

Gay For Boy Gets Anally Barebacked By A Macho Latino Stud

582.1k 100% 13min - 1080p

The fantasy of premiering a straight guy's ass - Magic Javi & Koldo Goran

378.7k 100% 27sec - 1080p

Straight Guy Caught Shoplifting With Closeted Gay Friend Made To Fuck

55k 100% 8min - 1080p

Straight dude has first time gay fuck with step brother's friend

413 7min - 1080p

Straight gamers Reese Rideout and Nico Coopa got horny after their avatars hooked up then they met and dive into first time gay anal and oral action

4.5k 80% 6min - 1080p

Straight married with big ass first time at GloryHole... Pay attention to the dialogues! (FULL ON RED)

19.9k 100% 1min 5sec - 1080p